Key Takeaways

  • Hidden problems like dry rot, water damage, or failing stucco often only appear once washing and prep begin.
  • A good painter pauses, assesses the issue in person, and explains your options before doing anything extra.
  • A painting change order puts the added work, price, and schedule impact in writing for your approval.
  • Some repairs can wait, but damage that affects the new paint or the building usually needs attention now.
  • Older homes are more likely to have surprises, so ask about them before the job starts.

When painters find hidden damage mid-project, they should stop, show you the problem, and give you a written change order to approve before any extra work begins.

A painting estimate is based on what the painter can see, and some of the most important problems hide under old paint, behind trim, or at the base of a wall. Greg Owens, owner of McCarthy Painting, puts it simply: “almost every project has things that we can uncover.” What matters is not whether something turns up, but how your painter handles it when it does. That’s where a painting change order comes in, and understanding it ahead of time takes most of the stress out of the moment.

What Counts as a Mid-Project Problem?

A mid-project problem is anything that changes the scope of the job after it has started. It usually falls into one of two groups.

Hidden Damage Found During Prep

Power washing, scraping, and sanding remove the top layer of a surface, which is often the first time anyone sees what’s underneath. Common discoveries include dry rot in trim or siding, water damage around windows, cracked or separating stucco, rusted metal, and caulking that has failed behind old paint. Interior jobs have surprises too: drywall patches that crack once sanded, water stains that bleed through primer, or damaged walls hidden behind old wallpaper. Greg describes a recent Mill Valley job where “during the power washing, we uncovered some dry rot, and the siding is rotten where it meets the foundation of the house.”

Changes the Client Requests

Not every change is a problem. Sometimes the homeowner decides to add something once the work is underway. Greg notes that clients sometimes skip rooms in the original estimate, then “they see the beauty of this new paint job, and they wanna add it.” Accent colors, extra rooms, doors, and trim upgrades all fall into this category.

What a Good Painter Does First: Stop, Assess, and Explain

Stop Before Covering It Up

Painting over damage is the quickest way to hide a problem and the surest way to make it worse. A professional crew pauses work on that area as soon as something looks wrong, rather than priming over soft wood or cracked stucco to stay on schedule. If the homeowner isn’t available right away, the crew should protect the exposed area and move to another part of the house, rather than leaving bare wood open to the weather.

Assess It in Person

Someone with experience should look at the problem directly, not just a photo sent from the crew. At McCarthy Painting, Greg explains, “myself or one of my project managers will come out to the property, assess what’s going on, and give a new price for that additional work.” That visit answers the key questions: how far the damage goes, what caused it, and what it will take to fix properly. Photos are still useful, especially if you’re away during the job, but they work best alongside an in-person look from someone who can judge how deep the problem goes.

Explain Your Options Clearly

You should come away knowing what was found, why it matters, and what your choices are. For example, damaged wood may be repairable with epoxy in one spot and need full replacement in another. Some issues are cosmetic and can safely wait for a future project, while others, like an active leak or spreading rot, really shouldn’t. A good painter walks you through each option in plain language and tells you honestly which ones they’d fix first.

What a Good Painter Does First: Stop, Assess, and Explain

What Is a Change Order in Painting?

The Basic Definition

If you’ve ever wondered what is a change order, it’s a written update to your original agreement. A painting change order describes the additional or different work, the price for that work, and any effect on the schedule. You review it and approve it before the extra work starts. It doesn’t replace your original contract. It adds to it, so everything you already agreed to still applies.

What It Should Include

A clear change order typically lists:

  • The problem or request: what was found or what you asked to add
  • The work: the repairs or extra painting needed, in plain terms
  • The price: the added cost for that specific work, separate from the original job
  • The schedule impact: whether it adds days to the project
  • Your approval: a signature or written confirmation before work begins

How Change Orders Are Reviewed and Approved

Reviewing the Details

Take a few minutes to read the change order and ask questions. A fair one is specific: it names the area, the type of repair, and the materials. If something is unclear, ask the painter to show you the damage and explain how they arrived at the price. Keep a copy of every approved change order with your original contract, so you have a complete record of the job.

When Materials Need to Be Sourced

Some repairs depend on finding the right materials first. On the Mill Valley job, the damaged siding was “a unique siding, Eichler-type siding,” so Greg needed to “see if we can source that siding and then give that customer a price based on the materials that we can find.” If an exact match isn’t available, he says, “we’re gonna have to come up with something else to fill it that looks okay, and we’ll have that conversation with that customer.” In cases like this, the change order may come a few days after the problem is found.

Giving Your Approval

Once you agree, approve it in writing, so both sides know exactly what was agreed. Avoid a quick verbal “go ahead” in the driveway. Even a short email reply confirming the change is better than a conversation nobody remembers the same way later.

How Hidden Problems Affect the Schedule

Repairs Come Before Paint

Damaged areas have to be repaired, primed, and sometimes left to cure before they can be painted. Crews can often keep working elsewhere on the home meanwhile.

Material Lead Times

Common repairs often use standard materials and move quickly. Matching specialty siding, older trim profiles, or custom millwork can take longer, especially if the original product is no longer made. Ask whether the rest of the job can keep moving while materials are on order, so the whole project doesn’t sit idle.

Weather Still Matters

On exterior jobs, a repair delay can push painting into rainier weather, so a good painter explains how a change affects the timeline, not just the price.

How Hidden Problems Affect the Schedule

How to Avoid Surprises Before the Job Starts

Ask About Older Homes Up Front

Older homes are more likely to hide problems. Greg says McCarthy tries “to tell the customers up front especially if it’s an old house, that there very well could be other things that we run into.” Ask your painter what they typically find on homes like yours.

Walk the Property Together

During the estimate, point out any areas you’re already worried about, like soft trim, peeling near windows, or past leaks. The more the painter sees early, the fewer surprises later. It also helps to ask whether the estimate notes any areas that might need repair once prep begins, so a possible issue is already on paper before work starts.

Ask How Changes Are Handled

Before signing, ask how the company handles hidden damage and added requests. A clear answer, like “we stop, show you, and send a written change order,” is a good sign.

Looking for a Painter Who Explains Every Change Up Front?

A painting change order isn’t a sign that something went wrong. It’s how a good painter handles the reality of older homes and evolving plans: stop, assess, explain, and put it in writing before any extra work begins.

At McCarthy Painting, we provide expert residential and commercial painting services across San Francisco, Marin, and surrounding California areas, including specialized protective coatings, surface preparation, and long-lasting exterior solutions. Our team ensures proper application and durability for both homes and commercial properties, delivering high-quality finishes built to withstand time and weather.

Contact us today at 415-383-2640 to schedule your free estimate, or explore our Residential, Commercial, and Our Services pages to learn more.

McCarthy Painting

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I say no to a change order?

Yes. You can decline added work, though the painter may explain the risks of painting over damage. If a repair affects how the new paint will hold up, ask whether skipping it limits their workmanship guarantee.

What happens if the painter can’t match my original siding or trim?

The painter should present alternatives, such as a close match or a replacement material that blends in once painted, and talk through the options with you before choosing one.

Can I add rooms or colors after the job has started?

Usually, yes. The painter will review the added work, provide a price, and confirm any change to the schedule before starting it.

Should a change order always be in writing?

Yes. California’s rules for home improvement contracts call for changes to be put in writing, and a written change order protects both you and the painter.

Who decides whether a hidden problem needs to be fixed right away?

You make the final decision, based on the painter’s advice. Damage that would cause the new paint to fail, or that is spreading, is usually best fixed before painting continues.

Greg-Owens

Editorial Review by Greg Owens, Owner & CEO, McCarthy Painting Company

Greg Owens is the Owner and CEO of McCarthy Painting Company, a family-owned painting contractor serving Marin County and the San Francisco Bay Area since 1969. Having worked with the company since 1990, Greg has more than three decades of hands-on experience in residential and commercial painting, surface preparation, protective coatings, wood restoration, and long-term property maintenance. Under his leadership, McCarthy Painting has completed projects for homeowners, commercial property managers, and organizations throughout the Bay Area while maintaining a reputation for quality craftsmanship, professionalism, and exceptional customer service. Greg reviews educational content to help property owners make informed decisions about painting, maintenance, and protecting their investment.